Skip to content

Magnetoreception mechanism in animals

Unsolved Archive

How do migratory animals like birds, sea turtles, and some fish sense Earth's magnetic field well enough to navigate across continents or oceans, and does this rely on a genuinely quantum-mechanical process inside a light-sensitive protein in their eyes?

Posed by Wolfgang Wiltschko (demonstrated magnetic compass orientation in European robins), 1972
Like0
History and references

Partly settled. Some of it is understood, some is still argued about.

Wolfgang Wiltschko's 1972 experiments first demonstrated that European robins use an internal magnetic compass for orientation, launching decades of research into how any animal could sense a magnetic field as weak as Earth's. The leading hypothesis, developed since the 1970s-2000s, proposes that light striking the protein cryptochrome in the retina creates pairs of chemically reactive 'radical' electrons whose quantum spin states are subtly influenced by the ambient magnetic field, altering the protein's chemistry in a way the animal could perceive. Laboratory studies through the early-to-mid 2020s have shown cryptochrome from migratory birds is magnetically sensitive in vitro and behavioral experiments support radical-pair involvement, but a complete, undisputed chain from magnetic field to cryptochrome chemistry to nerve signal to behavior in a living animal has not yet been fully demonstrated.

A songbird crossing an ocean at night may be literally seeing Earth's magnetic field thanks to quantum spin physics happening inside a protein in its eye.

Explanations that circulated
  • That magnetoreception has been conclusively proven to work via the radical-pair quantum mechanism in cryptochrome — this remains the leading and best-supported hypothesis (with strong in-vitro and behavioral evidence through the early 2020s), but a magnetically sensitive radical-pair reaction has not yet been demonstrated to directly drive animal behavior in vivo, and a competing magnetite-based mechanism may also contribute in some species
References

Solutions 0

Nobody has posted a solution here yet. Solutions written on Problempedia are credited to the people who write them.

Discussion 0

Sign in to join the discussion