Why a spinning egg stands up
Why does a hard-boiled egg spun fast enough on a table rise up and spin on its end?
History and references
Settled in 2002 by H. Keith Moffatt & Yutaka Shimomura (Cambridge).
That a spun hard-boiled egg rises onto its end while a raw egg does not is an old kitchen-table curiosity that lacked a rigorous dynamical explanation for decades. In 2002 Keith Moffatt and Yutaka Shimomura at Cambridge showed, using a gyroscopic approximation valid at high spin rates, that slipping friction between the shell and table exerts a torque that drives the spin axis from horizontal to vertical, with the final vertical state being the one that minimizes kinetic energy for a fixed 'Jellett constant.' The explanation also accounts for why raw eggs, whose fluid interior does not spin rigidly with the shell, fail to rise.
A boiled egg spinning on a kitchen table slowly stands itself up on end, driven by nothing more exotic than ordinary sliding friction and a hidden conserved quantity.
Explanations that circulated
- Naive intuition that spinning objects always lower their center of mass to minimize energy predicts the egg should stay lying down, not rise - this misses the crucial role of frictional torque.
- Attributing the rise purely to the egg's asymmetric (prolate) shape, without accounting for slipping friction between shell and table, fails to explain why a raw (fluid-filled) egg does not rise the same way.
References
- Classical dynamics: Spinning eggs - a paradox resolved, H. K. Moffatt, Y. Shimomura, Nature, 2002
Solutions 0
Sign in or create an account to publish a solution